Historical Evolution of Et Estimating Methods

Historical Evolution of Et Estimating Methods

HISTORICAL EVOLUTION OF ET ESTIMATING METHODS A Century of Progress by Marvin E. Jensen 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 1 INTRODUCTION This a partial condensation of a previous paper: Jensen & Allen (2000), 2000 ASAE National Irrig. Symposium

it includes developments since 2000 In this paper, I also place more emphasis on my involvement reviewing old docs, early est methods , and current literature added pictures of key personnel methods based on theory and European methods dissemination and adoption of new U.S. estimating methods new models based on satellite-imagery (SEBAL and METRIC) development of the ASCE Manual 70, FAO-56, the ASCE Standardized Reference ET Equation, and the 2nd edition of ASCE Manual 70 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 2

EARLY ESTIMATING METHODS Early need for ET estimates Early estimating methods initially, estimates were only for seasonal estimates then estimates were made for monthly periods Mean air temperature was the primary weather variable, or temperature above 32 F Secondary variables were: relative humidity percent of daylight hours 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop

3 EARLY IRRIGATION STUDIES Irrigation development began the mid-1800s deliveries to farms varied widely and exceeded CU over-irrigation was the first and most serious mistake made by early settlers (Buffam, 1892) Irrigation investigations began around 1900 Duty of Water measurements were made involving water delivered to canals and water delivered to farms units were acres per 1 cfs, or depth applied 12-Mar-2010

ARS/CSU ET Workshop 4 RESULTS OF MY EARLY WORK My involvement began in 1960-monthly k-values From about 100 values for full crop cover, ETp = (0.014 T 0.37) Rs approximated ET from a crop like alfalfa 1962 preliminary report, estimating ET from Rs Publication Jensen and Haise (1963), objective encourage engineers, soil scientists and agronomists to begin thinking about solar energy as a primary variable in

estimating ET (and to motivate) rather than only air temp 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 5 EARLY WATER USE STUDIES 1897Joint USDA-Exp. Stn investigations started and continued under various departments investigations were transferred to SCS in 1935 1890-1920 measurements of Duty of water acres that could be irrigated with a constant flow

or depth of water applied at the farm turnout, it was called net duty of water Progress report, ASCE Duty of Water committee presented in 1927 by O.W. Israelson published in 1930 (Anonymous, 1930) 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 6 EARLY TRANSPIRATION STUDIES 1902 USDA Bur. of Plant Industry established Briggs, biophysicist, and Shantz, plant

physiologist, conducted classic studies in eastern Colorado from 1913 to 1916 they recognized that solar radiation was the primary cause of cyclic changes in environmental factors developed hourly equations of T as a function of Rs and temperature rise; and Rs and VP deficit 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 7 EARLY ESTIMATING METHODS 1924 Hedke proposed a method based on heat

available defined as degree-days (temp x days) 1942 Blaney and Morin proposed a method based on mean temperature, daylight hours and humidity 1942 Lowry and Johnson proposed a method based on maximum temperature above 32F 1948 Thornthwaite proposed a method based on mean monthly temperature. He recognized its limitations such as why PET at a given temperature is not the same everywhere 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 8

Blaney-Criddle Method Most widely known method (1945, 1950, 1952, 1962) up to the 1970s U = KF = kf k monthly CU coefficient based on temperature f = t p/100 where t = mean monthly temperature, F, and p = mean monthly percent of annual daytime hours 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 9

Harry F Blaney 1966 Receiving ASAE John Deere Medal 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 10 ICID Vice President 1970-1973 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop

11 Why Not Ra instead of %DL? %DL/%DL(max) and Ra/Ra(max) 20 degrees N Lat 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4

0.2 0.0 0 50 100 150 200 Ra

12-Mar-2010 250 300 350 % DL ARS/CSU ET Workshop 12 1.2

40deg NLat 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0 50 100

150 Ra 1.2 200 250 300 350 250

300 350 %DL 60deg NLat 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0

50 100 150 Ra 12-Mar-2010 200 %DL ARS/CSU ET Workshop

13 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 14 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 15 Transition Methods in the U.S.

Temperature and solar radiation Jensen-Haise (1963) ETalfalfa ref = 0.014 (Tf 0.37) Rs (Western USA) Stephens and Steward (1963) ETgrass ref = 0.0082 (Tf 0.19) Rs (Florida) Hargeaves and Samani (1985); Hargreaves et al. (1985) ETgrassref = 0.0023 TD0.5 (Tc + 17.8) Ra 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop

16 Methods Based on Theory The Bowen Ratio, BR (Bowen, 1926) (BR = T/eT/eT/ee ) Was used for estimate evaporation from water in the 1930s, but was not used to estimate ET from land until Penman (1948) Penman applied physics and [ET = (Rn G)/(1 + BR)] the Bowen Ratio, energy balance along with the the rates of sensible heat and vapor transfer Penman laid the foundation for later development of improved estimating methods (Penman, 1948, 1956, and 1963) Surface resistance was added to the Penman equation (Penman and Long 1960; Monteith 1965; & Rijtema 1965) Today, ET measurement methods include eddy covariance,

boundary layer theory, remote sensing and energy balance or a combination of these methods 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 17 Penman Equation (1948) E = ( RRn R R+ R R REa R)/( + ) R+ R) ( + )Eq. 16) E = evaporation = the slope of saturated vapor pressure curve = psychrometric constant Rn = net radiation at crop surface = latent heat of vaporization

Ea was an empirical wind function (like Rohwers (1931) equation 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 18 Howard L Penman Pres., Royal Meteor. Soc. 1961-63 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop

19 John L Monteith Pres., Royal Meteor. Soc. 1978-80 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 20 Other Estimating Methods The European engineers progressed more rapidly Makkink (1957) developed a formula for potential ET

based on solar radiation & air temp Turc (1960, 61) developed a formula based on 10day mean air temperature and solar radiation Rijtema (1958) a formula for individual crops using crop factors and length of growing season Olivier (1961), a formula for monthly CU using wet bulb depression and clear sky radiation factors Jensen (1968) proposed estimating ET using alfalfa ref x Kc -- known as the two-step process 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 21 Some details of my involvement

USDA-SCS Request to ARS-USDA calculate crop coefficients for the B-C formula Howard Haise and Harry Blaney solicited data from ARS researchers the calculated monthly coefficients varied widely I prepared a new questionnaire basic soil water and climate data were requested criteria were established for screening the data new calculations, resulted in ~1000 ET rates for short time periods along with estimated solar radiation 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop

22 RESULTS From about 100 values of ET for full crop cover ET = (0.014 T 0.37) Rs approximated ET from a crop with full cover like alfalfa with 30 to 50 cm (12-20 in.) of growth A 1962 preliminary report, estimating ET from Rs, prepared for a workshop on estimating ET Publication by Jensen and Haise (1963) had as its objective to encourage (& motivate) engineers soil scientists and agronomists to consider solar energy as the primary variable controlling ET 12-Mar-2010

ARS/CSU ET Workshop 23 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 24 Adopting & Disseminating New Estimating Methods Though the physicist still has some problems he can solve by himself, much of his future contribution to understanding

evaporation in agriculture must be in collaboration with the biologist and soil scientists (Penman, 1956) In 1966 we organized a conference of ET specialists in Chicago In 1966, I was also asked to chair the ASCE committee on Water Requirements New members were added to the ASCE WR committee Control members were Burman, U of Wyo; Collins, SCS; Gibbs, USBR; and Johnson, USGS Harry Blaney remained on the committee 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 25

Dissemination Continued An ASCE report on CU was prepared in 1973, it was widely distributed (Jensen ed. 1974) and was the start of ASCE Manual 70 (Jensen et al. 1990) I left the committee for three years while serving on the ASCE I&D executive committee Committee members continued work on the manual In 1986 an ASCE Manual subcommittee was formed consisting of Allen, Burman, Blatchley, Jensen (chm), Johns, Stone and Wright, eventually resulting in the ASCE Manual 70 Evapotranspiration and Irrigation Water Requirements (Jensen et al. 1990) 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop

26 Dissemination Continued Rick Allen published a detailed paper in the Agronomy Journal (Allen et al. 1989) FAO organized a consultation for revising FAO-24 Crop Water Requirements with participants from seven countries (Smith et al. 1991) (Allen, Jensen and Pruitt represented the U.S.) Draft copies of ASCE Manual 70 was a key reference at this 1990 conference 12-Mar-2010

ARS/CSU ET Workshop 27 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 28 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 29

12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 30 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 31 12-Mar-2010

ARS/CSU ET Workshop 32 SATELLITE-IMAGERY MODELS In the Netherlands, the surface energy balance model for land was developed by Bastiaanssen et al. in 1998 (SEBAL) In the U.S., a model was developed by Allen et al. (2007) using some of the basic principles in SEBAL, called a model for Mapping Evapotranspiration at high Resolution using Internalized Calibration (METRIC) 12-Mar-2010

ARS/CSU ET Workshop 33 Reference Crop x Crop Coefficient Known as the two-step method widely used Was proposed in 1968 with alfalfa as the ref crop Crop coefficient -- Similar to that proposed by Wijk and de Vries (1954) Results can be very robust requires judgment in selecting and applying crop coefficients Example: Comparison with SEBAL for IID for wateryear 1998, +2% all areas to +5% agr. land (Jensen & Walter 2002) 12-Mar-2010

ARS/CSU ET Workshop 34 Recent Methods The Irrigation Association requested the ASCE ET Committee to recommend a single procedure for est. reference ET in the U.S. An ASCE task committee developed such a procedure described in 2000 and published a report in 2005 (ASCE-EWRI 2005) Remote sensing using satellite data (SEBAL and METRIC) Remote sensing used to estimate Kc (grd, aircraft, satellite) procedures for estimating Kc from ground cover and height expanded the FAO Kc database (Allen and Pereira 2009) A one-step estimating method theory (Shuttleworth 2006) was tested in Australia (Shuttleworth & Wallace 2009)

Also known as Direct Penman-Montheith method The 2nd ed. of Manual 70 is nearing completion 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 35 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 36 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS

This brief presentation summarizes a century of progress in the development of modern methods of estimating seasonal, daily and hourly ET (Only two centuries ago Dalton first described the hydrologic cycle) Most of the progress in the U.S. was made during the last third of a century. ET is a complex process involving plants, soils, local weather such as wind speed and humidity, and solar and long-wave radiation Many scientists and engineers were involved in the development of current, modern ET estimating technology My association with development process was a learning experience contacts with leading U.S & intl scientists and engineers was rewarding

I have emphasized my involvement its been my work for the past 50 yrs I may have missed some recent developmentsI tried to highlight main items For a recent and more detailed review, see Farahani et al. (2007) (Photos follow, time permitting) 12-Mar-2010

ARS/CSU ET Workshop 37 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 38 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 39

12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 40 12-Mar-2010 ARS/CSU ET Workshop 41

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Topic 1: Introduction to Economics 1 (The Price System)

    Topic 1: Introduction to Economics 1 (The Price System)

    We solve equations for r and Y. * The Great Depression (1) Was the Great Depression caused by "shocks" to the IS curve or "shocks" to the LM curve? The Spending Hypothesis A collapse in spending caused the IS curve...


    PELVIS AND LOWER LIMB Grant Kennedy ... Judet views (AP, 45 degree iliac oblique, 45 degree obturator oblique) CT scan (x-ray negative but suspicious; clarifying operative or non-operative) Judet-Letournel Classification System: Simple (5 types) vs. Complex (combos) Acetabular Fractures Judet...
  • Critical Thinking

    Critical Thinking

    Find out what the animals are! (for example, "To run away or escape" could be a "flea") 1. hair-control foam2. very exposed3. tellin' falsities4. a lamenting cry5. a dull person6. a precious or loved one7. first you get a parking...
  • Heinrich-Lanz-Schule II Gewerbliche Berufsschule Mannheim

    Heinrich-Lanz-Schule II Gewerbliche Berufsschule Mannheim

    Schulkonferenz 2008/2009 am 03. 11. 08 Herzlich willkommen! Tagesordnung Begrüßung und Vorstellungsrunde Allgemeine Aufgaben der Schulkonferenz
  • Landforms on the Globe - SharpSchool

    Landforms on the Globe - SharpSchool

    Landforms on the Globe 2.06 Identify and use models, maps, and aerial photographs as ways of representing landforms. Landforms are features that make up the Earth's surface. Some landforms are created by wind, water, ice, and gravity.
  • Slogan Examples   Just Do It. im lovin it

    Slogan Examples Just Do It. im lovin it

    Slogan Examples Just Do It. i'm lovin' it eat fresh. Think different. Because You're Worth It. Like a Good Neighbor… Maybe she's born with it… Melts in Your Mouth, Not in Your Hands. Like a rock. The quicker picker-upper. Once...
  • Pop Art Portraits - Mr. Michael McCloskey

    Pop Art Portraits - Mr. Michael McCloskey

    Vincent van Gogh painted "Starry Night" What do you notice about his style of painting? What do you notice about his style of painting? Lots of colors Swirly lines Big bright stars Vincent van Gogh- Starry Night With a pencil:...
  • 2010 Ops Workshop - trlmo.com

    2010 Ops Workshop - trlmo.com

    8WR OPS Workshop 2015 Part II ... Rivers 2015 Operations Workshop * SUMR Passenger Policy Non-Coast Guard on AUX Facilities No non-AUX guests or passengers (including family) on facilities unless: Order Issuing Authority (OIA) authorizes Process - Request 2 weeks...